Manuscript Readiness Level (MRL)

Rate each criterion and add the selected points.

Pre-Evaluation Criteria

Maximum: 100
CriterionStrong
Level 1
Fair
Level 2
Poor
Level 3
TitleInformative and representative of the article.532
AbstractIncludes the problem, purpose, method, findings, and implications.1052
KeywordsSearchable and representative; at least 3 single-word keywords, preferably 5.532
IntroductionExplains significance, prior research, gaps, novelty, and purpose.15105
MethodAppropriate, clear, replicable procedures.1052
ResultsReports relevant evidence through readable text, tables, or figures.15105
DiscussionInterprets findings in relation to previous research.20155
ConclusionConnects the main finding to the research objective.1041
ReferencesPrioritise primary sources (~80%) from the past decade; use reference software.1051
Total score1006025

Decision Matrix

ScoreGuidance
85–100Ready for assessment; limited revision may be needed.
70–84Minor revision may be needed.
50–69Major revision may be needed.
25–49Substantial preparation needed; risk of initial rejection.

Notes

Scores do not predict acceptance. MATALINGUA editors decide publication after editorial assessment and peer review.