Allegations of Misconduct
Concerns about submitted or published work may be reported through Contact Us. Include the manuscript identifier or article title, a clear description of the concern, and supporting evidence such as source links, documents, or specific passages. Reports may concern plagiarism, data or image manipulation, authorship, undisclosed conflicts, ethical approval, duplicate publication, or interference with peer review.
Initial assessment
The editorial office records the concern and refers it to an editor without a conflict. Reports are assessed on their evidence, including reports whose sender cannot be identified when enough information is available. Relevant records are preserved, and identifying information is shared only as needed to assess the case.
Investigation and response
The editor checks the evidence and normally gives the authors a fair opportunity to explain. Review or publication may be paused while a concern is examined. The journal may request data or documentation and seek advice from an independent specialist. Where a matter requires institutional investigation, the editor may refer it to the relevant institution, employer, funder, or ethics body.
A complaint concerning an editor must be referred to another independent editor or the publisher. The person named in the allegation must not control the investigation or decision.
Outcomes and appeal
Possible outcomes include no further action, a request for revision, rejection, a correction, an expression of concern, or retraction. Decisions depend on the evidence and the reliability of the scholarly record. A retraction may be needed for a serious honest error even when misconduct has not been established.
The journal will communicate its decision to the affected parties as confidentiality permits. A reasoned appeal with new evidence or an identified procedural error may be sent through the same contact route and will be considered by an uninvolved editor or the publisher. No fixed investigation period is promised.
Policy updated: 30 October 2026.