Peer-Review Process

SPORTNEXT uses double-anonymous peer review: reviewer identities are withheld from authors, and author identities are withheld from reviewers during review. Research articles and scholarly reviews that pass editorial screening are assessed by at least two independent reviewers.

Editorial screening

An editor checks each submission for relevance to the journal, manuscript completeness, research ethics, originality, and readiness for review. A manuscript may be returned for technical changes or rejected at this stage. Screening does not guarantee external review or acceptance.

External review

Editors select reviewers for subject and methodological expertise and assess potential conflicts of interest. Authors must supply an anonymised manuscript and remove identifying details from the document and file properties. Identifying ethics or acknowledgement details may be supplied separately for editorial checks.

Reviewers assess the contribution, methods, evidence, clarity, references, and ethical conduct of the work. They provide reasoned recommendations and must keep submissions confidential. Reviewers must decline assignments when a conflict prevents an impartial assessment.

Revision and decision

The editor considers the reports and may reject the manuscript, request minor or major revisions, or accept it. Authors should respond to each review comment and explain any requested change they do not make. Revised manuscripts may return to reviewers. An additional reviewer may be consulted when reports differ substantially.

The editor makes the publication decision; reviewer recommendations are advisory. Manuscripts authored by an editor or board member must be handled by an independent editor, and the author must not participate in the decision.

Appeals

Authors may submit a reasoned appeal through Contact Us, identifying the decision and any factual or procedural error. An editor without a conflict will consider the appeal. The journal does not promise acceptance or a fixed review period.

Policy updated: 30 October 2026.